Beautyrest Vs Sealy: Which Mattress Reigns Supreme?

Our Testing Process

At Sleep Advisor, we have a group of mattress experts who carefully test each mattress to give you honest and fair advice. We use a special way to check the mattresses, making sure we look at things like comfort, support, cooling, and price. Our goal is to help you find the mattress that suits you best, without any bias or favoritism. You can trust that our suggestions come from real testing and experience, not just opinions. If you want to know more about how we test mattresses, you can read our full product review process on our website.

In This Article

This article will help you decide which mattress is better for you: Beautyrest or Sealy. Both brands are very popular in the US, and they have different types of mattresses. We will compare three models from each brand, looking at their benefits, feel, how they are made, and how much they cost. By the end of this, you will have a clear idea of which mattress might be the right fit for your needs and preferences.

Introduction to Beautyrest and Sealy

Beautyrest and Sealy are two well-known mattress brands that many people in the US recognize. Both started making mattresses a long time ago, way back in the 1800s, and they still make their mattresses right here in the United States. You can usually find their mattresses in stores near you, but now you can also buy them online and have them delivered to your home. These brands are trusted because they have been around for a long time and know how to make quality mattresses. In this comparison, we will look mainly at Sealy’s Hybrid line and Beautyrest’s popular mattresses to help you see how they are similar and different.

Comparison At a Glance

Here is a quick look at what each brand is best for, how much their mattresses cost, and some special features they have:

Key Similarities

Both Beautyrest and Sealy make hybrid mattresses. A hybrid mattress means it has different layers, including coils (which are springs that help support your body), memory foam (which molds to your shape), and polyfoam (which adds extra comfort). This mix of materials helps the mattress feel good and support your body well. Both brands offer mattresses with different firmness levels, so you can pick a mattress that feels soft, medium, or firm based on what you like and how you sleep. Another similarity is the warranty: both Beautyrest and Sealy give you a 10-year warranty. This means if your mattress has a problem during this time, they will fix it or replace it. Ten years is a standard warranty length in the mattress world.

Key Differences

Even though the brands have some things in common, they also have important differences. First, Beautyrest mattresses usually cost more because they are made as luxury beds. Sealy’s mattresses are more affordable but still good quality. Second, Beautyrest mattresses are often thicker than Sealy’s. Thicker mattresses have more layers, which can make them feel more comfortable and luxurious. Third, Beautyrest mattresses have special cooling features, which make them better for people who get hot at night. Sealy mattresses are good for cooling too, but not as advanced as Beautyrest. Lastly, when your new mattress arrives, Beautyrest offers free white glove delivery. This means someone will bring the mattress into your home, set it up for you, and take your old mattress away. Sealy only offers free standard delivery, so you will have to bring the mattress inside and set it up yourself.

Clear comparison table for Beautyrest vs Sealy mattresses based on the key points

Beautyrest Black Hybrid vs Sealy Hybrid Essentials

Beautyrest Black Hybrid Mattress
The Beautyrest Black Hybrid comes in three firmness options: medium, plush, and ultra-plush. This means it can feel soft for people who don’t like very firm beds. The mattress has thick layers of foam, between 4 to 5.5 inches, that gently hug your body, which gives a feeling like you are sleeping “in” the mattress rather than “on” it. This is great for side sleepers because it helps relieve pressure on shoulders and hips. It also has cooling foams and breathable coils that keep the mattress from getting too warm. Couples like this mattress because it blocks motion well, so you don’t feel your partner moving at night. The mattress also has strong edges, so you can sleep near the sides comfortably.

Sealy Hybrid Essentials Mattress
Sealy’s Hybrid Essentials mattress is firmer, with a firmness level around 7 out of 10 (1 being softest). This makes it a good choice for stomach sleepers and back sleepers who like firm support. It has a coil system called DuraFlex Coil Edge System that makes the edges sturdy. The mattress cover pulls away moisture to keep you dry, and gel memory foam with breathable coils help keep you cool. The coils work independently to give good support and reduce motion transfer.

How They Compare
The biggest difference is the feel: Beautyrest Black is softer and thicker with more foam, which makes it better for side sleepers. Sealy Hybrid Essentials is firmer and better for stomach sleepers. Both support back sleepers well, but your choice depends on how soft or firm you like your bed. The Beautyrest Black costs about twice as much as the Sealy Hybrid Essentials.

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond vs Sealy Hybrid Performance

Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond Mattress
This mattress is very thick and soft, with over 6 inches of foam that relieves pressure. It comes in medium, plush, or ultra-plush firmness, so you can pick how soft or firm you want it. It uses cooling technology in almost every layer, so it feels cool and comfortable at night. The thick foam layers and coils help stop you from feeling your partner’s movements, which is good if you share the bed.

Sealy Hybrid Performance Mattress
Sealy offers this mattress in two firmness options: plush (medium-soft) and firm (medium-firm). It has Posturepedic Technology, which means there are more coils in the middle part of the mattress where your hips and lower back need extra support. This helps keep your spine aligned. It also has three layers of comfort foam including gel memory foam that cushions your body and helps keep you cool. The coils move independently, which helps with motion isolation.

How They Compare
The Beautyrest Harmony Lux Diamond is best for side sleepers and people who want a very soft, luxurious mattress. The Sealy Hybrid Performance is better for stomach sleepers, people who weigh more, and those with back pain because of its firmer support and extra coils in the middle. Both mattresses cool well and are durable. The Sealy mattress is more affordable but offers fewer firmness choices.

Beautyrest Black vs Sealy Hybrid Premium

Beautyrest Black Mattress
This is the most luxurious mattress from Beautyrest. It uses advanced foam and coil technology for great support and comfort. You can choose a medium-firm feel or add a soft pillow top. The mattress is designed to sleep cool, with special cooling foams and breathable coils. It is also great for people with aches and pains because it supports the spine and relieves pressure very well.

Sealy Hybrid Premium Mattress
Sealy’s Hybrid Premium mattress has three firmness options: ultra-plush (soft), plush (medium), and firm (hard). It has zoned coils with more support in the middle, which helps keep your spine in a healthy position. The cover and foam are designed to keep you cool all night. This mattress is thick and durable, made with high-quality materials.

How They Compare
Both mattresses are thick and supportive, with strong cooling features. The Sealy Hybrid Premium is better for larger people because of its zoned support. Beautyrest Black is known for having even better cooling and pressure relief, which can be very helpful if you get hot or have body aches. Both cost a lot, but Beautyrest Black is usually more expensive.

Beautyrest Mattresses Are Slightly Thicker

Beautyrest mattresses are often a bit thicker than Sealy mattresses. Thickness can mean more layers of foam and coils, which can make the mattress feel more comfortable and soft. However, both brands make mattresses that are thicker than most regular beds, so either way, you will get a mattress with good support and cushion. They also have very similar sizes for twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king beds, so you can pick the size you want without worry.

Trial Period

Both Beautyrest and Sealy offer a risk-free 100-night trial. This means you can try the mattress in your own home for about three months. If you don’t like it, you can return it for free. One small difference is that Sealy asks you to wait 30 days before you can return the mattress, but Beautyrest does not have this waiting period. This trial makes it easier to choose a mattress because you don’t have to worry about getting stuck with one that doesn’t feel right.

Warranty

Both brands give a 10-year limited warranty on their mattresses. This means if something is wrong with your mattress because of a manufacturing defect, they will fix or replace it during those 10 years. This is a normal warranty period in the mattress business and shows that both brands stand behind their products.

Which Brand Is Right for You?

If you want a very soft, luxurious mattress with extra cooling and thick foam layers, Beautyrest is a great choice. Their mattresses are made to feel plush and help reduce motion, so they are perfect if you like a cloud-like bed or share your bed with a partner. On the other hand, if you want a firmer mattress that costs less and offers strong support—especially if you have back pain or sleep on your stomach—Sealy’s hybrid mattresses might be better for you. Both brands let you try their mattresses risk-free for 100 nights, so you can see which one you like best before deciding. Remember, Beautyrest tends to be softer and more expensive, while Sealy is firmer and more affordable. Either way, you will be getting a mattress from a well-known company with good quality.